Had a magnetic screen that worked great for mild weather in early fall and spring, but during the hot summer and cold winter days needed something to help keep the heat and cold out. This works great. Not sure where some of the negative post concerning assembly are coming from. Had no trouble. Hanging rails wen up just fine, bracket attach with a screwdriver and then the clipped right in place. After they were put up, I did need to take the PVC strips down the trim the bottoms so they did not drag the ground. Only trouble I had was that for a while the stipes would stick together, but that seem to have gone away after about a week and a half. Seemed to be static.