I do not offer give a 5 star review, but since this is truly a "solid state item", with no moving parts and nothing to break (basically) I am giving it a 5 star review. Even though the finger holes are not as I would like.
This is really heavy (31lb's). This is a good thing, and a curse. The mass of the steel maintains a more even heat than my ceramic pizza stone.
The bottom of the pizza is more evenly browned.
I am giving it a 5 star rating indoor of the fact the edges while not sharp, are not as smooth (rounded, ergonomic or comfortable) as I would have liked. I will take a file to the edges (especially the finger holes, which are a nice touch (makes pulling the steel out of the oven easier (not easy, but easier). The holes are an instrumental feature that allows one to move the steel in/out of the oven with "confidence". Without these holes grabbing the steel and moving it would be "perilous" and a danger to the oven door and or floor - not to mention feet).
I have purchased from Vervor before (a water bath device to keep my chocolate at temperature for molding). They don't make truly professional products, but the products I have purchased from them are good. Not truly cheap. Acceptable.
I would buy from Vervor, again, knowing I am getting a decent product at a decent price (so far).